Contested Divorce Attorney in St. Louis, MO Protecting Your Rights When You Cannot Agree
When you and your spouse are far apart on custody, property, or support, and neither of you is willing to give much ground, you are facing a contested divorce. It is the more complicated path, it can take a year or more, and it may end in a trial where a St. Louis judge decides the issues you could not resolve yourselves. You do not have to walk into that alone, and you do not have to settle for an unfair outcome just to make it end.
At The Marks Law Firm, attorney Jonathan D. Marks has spent nearly three decades guiding St. Louis families through contested divorces, from the first temporary-orders hearing through discovery and, when necessary, trial. He is board certified as a family trial advocate by the National Board of Trial Advocacy, a Fellow of the American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers, and recognized by Best Lawyers in America and Super Lawyers for his trial and negotiation work. When the other side knows your attorney is fully prepared to try the case, they tend to negotiate more reasonably.
What Makes a Divorce "Contested"
A divorce becomes contested when you and your spouse disagree significantly on one or more of the central issues, child custody, the division of property and debt, or spousal and child support, and you cannot bridge the gap through negotiation. Some couples disagree about a single issue; others are apart on nearly everything.
A contested case follows a longer path than an uncontested one. You can expect a period of temporary orders, a discovery phase to establish the facts, settlement efforts along the way, and, if those efforts fail, a trial where each side presents evidence and a judge issues binding rulings. Understanding that arc ahead of time helps you make calmer, better decisions at each stage rather than reacting to each development as a crisis.
Temporary Orders: Stability While Your Case Is Pending
When spouses start out far apart, life still has to function while the divorce works its way toward resolution. Who lives in the marital home? Who has the children, and on what schedule? Who pays the mortgage and the monthly bills? How do you keep one spouse from draining marital accounts before anything is divided? These questions are answered through a motion pendente lite, often called a PDL motion, which asks the court for temporary relief that holds until the final judgment.
Temporary orders matter more than people expect. They set the practical status quo for months, and that status quo can influence how the final arrangement looks. Getting custody, support, and asset-preservation issues addressed early, and correctly, protects you for the rest of the case.
Discovery: Getting the Full Picture
Discovery is the formal process that forces both sides to put the facts on the table, and it is the backbone of a fair contested divorce. Its premise is simple: neither spouse should be able to hide information that affects property division, support, or custody. Missouri gives you several tools to compel that transparency.
Written interrogatories are questions your spouse must answer under oath. Requests for production require them to hand over documents, the bank statements, tax returns, retirement and business records that either confirm or contradict their claims. Requests for admission lock down undisputed facts so the case can focus on what is genuinely in dispute. Depositions capture sworn, recorded testimony outside court. And when a spouse will not cooperate, subpoenas compel banks, employers, and other third parties to produce records directly. Every Missouri dissolution also requires mandatory financial disclosures, including a Statement of Income and Expenses and a Statement of Marital and Non-Marital Property and Debts, and a Form 14 worksheet drives the child-support calculation.
Where you brought separate property into the marriage, Missouri applies a strict source-of-funds rule, which means tracing the money to prove what is non-marital. That tracing can require pulling statements back to the month before your marriage, and sometimes a forensic accountant. Discovery does not have to be a war: when both spouses are transparent, much of it can happen through informal exchange, which is faster and far less expensive. Formal, court-enforced discovery under the Missouri rules becomes necessary when good faith is missing, and the court can sanction a spouse who stonewalls, including ordering them to pay the fees their obstruction caused.
Talk through your options
If you have questions about your situation, we are here to help you understand your options and protect what matters most.
Depositions: What to Expect
A deposition is sworn testimony you give outside the courtroom, with attorneys present and a court reporter creating a transcript. It is one of the most powerful discovery tools because the questions are live, so your answers cannot be carefully drafted in advance, and inconsistencies tend to surface.
Depositions serve several purposes at once: clarifying facts, gathering evidence for trial or settlement, and letting each side assess how a witness will come across to a judge. If you are deposed, preparation is everything. Work through likely questions with your attorney beforehand, answer honestly, keep your answers brief and responsive without volunteering extra information, ask for clarification when a question is unclear, and stay calm even when the questioning gets pointed. Expect questions about the breakdown of the marriage, your finances and any undisclosed accounts, your children and your day-to-day involvement in their lives, and your own habits and history. How you handle a deposition can shape both your settlement leverage and your credibility at trial.
The Path to Resolution: Settlement or Trial
Most contested divorces in Missouri still resolve without a trial. As discovery fills in the facts and both sides see the real strengths and weaknesses of their positions, settlement often becomes possible, and the terms are written into a Marital Settlement Agreement that the court incorporates into your judgment. Thorough discovery is frequently what makes a fair settlement possible, because both parties are finally negotiating from reality rather than guesses.
When settlement is genuinely out of reach, the case proceeds to trial, where each side presents evidence, examines and cross-examines witnesses, and the judge decides every disputed issue. Choosing between settling and trying your case is one of the most consequential decisions you will make, and it deserves a clear-eyed look at both sides.
The Pros and Cons of Going to Trial
Trial has real advantages in the right case. It gives every disputed issue a full judicial review when your spouse simply will not be reasonable. It puts you on equal footing before an impartial judge who applies Missouri law rather than rewarding the more aggressive party. It unlocks the full force of formal discovery against a spouse who has been hiding the ball. And when settlement offers have been consistently unfair and the law supports your position, a trial can produce a better outcome than accepting an inadequate deal.
The drawbacks are just as real. Trial costs significantly more, because preparation, court time, and expert witnesses add up quickly. You give up control, handing the decision to a judge whose ruling is binding and may not match what either spouse wanted. The emotional toll is high, and because trials are public record, the private details of your marriage and finances are aired in open court. The timeline stretches out, sometimes by many months on a crowded docket. And when children are involved, the adversarial nature of trial can damage the co-parenting relationship you will rely on for years. The right answer depends on your specific facts, which is exactly the judgment an experienced attorney helps you make.
When a Trial Becomes Necessary
Despite the costs, trial is sometimes the right choice, or the only one. It may be necessary when settlement offers are grossly one-sided or far worse than the likely result under Missouri law, when no offers are on the table at all, or when your spouse reneges on agreements already reached. It also becomes necessary when one spouse will not negotiate in good faith, when there is domestic violence, when a spouse is hiding assets or income, when complex business valuation is in dispute, or when untreated substance abuse or mental-health issues affect safety or parenting. In those situations, a judge’s intervention is what protects you and your children.
Handling a High-Conflict Spouse Who Plays Dirty
Some contested divorces are difficult because the issues are complex. Others are difficult because one spouse decides to play dirty, through baseless accusations, hidden assets, manipulation, or using the children as leverage. The instinct to strike back is natural, but reacting in kind usually backfires, because it creates a he-said, she-said fog that makes it hard for a judge to see who is actually acting in good faith.
The stronger strategy is to divorce with dignity, which is not weakness but discipline. Document everything: gather a financial paper trail going back years, and keep a log of missed parenting time, disparaging comments relayed through the children, and other manipulation. Protect your children by refusing to badmouth their other parent, keeping their routine stable, and redirecting them when they are used as messengers. Limit the avenues for conflict by moving communication to written, time-stamped channels like email or a co-parenting app such as OurFamilyWizard, and keep your messages brief and factual, answering only what needs answering and ignoring the bait. Judges and guardians ad litem are trained to look through the chaos for the parent acting reasonably, so your composure is itself a legal asset. An experienced attorney serves as a strategic buffer here, reading your spouse’s moves through a legal lens and telling you when to act, when to document, and when silence is the strongest move.
Contested Custody and the Guardian ad Litem
When custody is genuinely disputed, a Missouri court will often appoint a Guardian ad Litem, a neutral attorney whose job is to investigate and recommend what is in the children’s best interests. The GAL’s recommendation carries real weight with the judge, so how you present yourself matters.
Show up prepared and cooperative, know the details of your children’s daily lives, from their teachers and doctors to their friends and interests, and demonstrate a genuine willingness to co-parent, because Missouri generally favors shared parenting. Be honest and never make allegations you cannot prove, since unsupported accusations are one of the fastest ways to lose credibility. Treat the GAL as the neutral investigator they are, keep the focus on your children rather than your own grievances, and run your approach by your attorney in advance.
The Cost Reality and How Missouri Handles Fees
Contested divorces cost more than uncontested ones, and discovery is frequently the single largest driver of that cost, especially when assets are complex or a spouse is uncooperative. Two features of Missouri law are worth knowing. Under RSMo Section 452.355, a court can order one spouse to pay a reasonable share of the other’s litigation costs, which matters when there is a significant income disparity between you. And under the Missouri discovery rules, a spouse who is evasive or who obstructs discovery can be sanctioned and ordered to cover the fees their conduct caused.
There is also a quieter risk: underspending. Agreeing to a property settlement without a full financial picture can cost you far more than the price of proper discovery, because in Missouri the division of property is final and generally cannot be reopened later. A measured approach, starting with cooperative exchange and turning to formal tools only when needed, usually serves you best, and an experienced attorney helps you calibrate exactly how much process your case actually requires.
Why Trial Credibility Matters in a Contested Case
In a contested divorce, your leverage in negotiation is tied to what happens if negotiation fails. A spouse who believes your attorney will fold rather than try the case has little reason to be reasonable. A spouse who knows your attorney is genuinely prepared to present a complex case to a judge has every reason to settle fairly.
That is why Jonathan’s board certification as a family trial advocate matters here specifically. It pairs the ability to negotiate a sound agreement with the credibility of a lawyer who tries cases when he has to. You get both the off-ramp of a fair settlement and the protection of someone ready to go the distance if your spouse leaves no other choice.
Frequently Asked Questions About Contested Divorce in St. Louis
How long does a contested divorce take in Missouri?
It varies widely with the level of conflict and the court’s docket, but a contested divorce commonly takes many months and can run a year or more, particularly if it goes to trial. Missouri also requires a minimum thirty-day waiting period after filing before any dissolution can be finalized. The more the two of you can resolve through negotiation, the faster it moves.
What is a PDL or temporary-orders motion?
A motion pendente lite asks the court for temporary relief while the divorce is pending, covering things like who stays in the home, the temporary custody and support arrangement, who pays which bills, and protecting marital assets from being depleted. These orders set the practical status quo until your final judgment.
What is discovery, and do we have to do it?
Discovery is the formal exchange of information through tools like interrogatories, document requests, depositions, and subpoenas. Not every case needs extensive formal discovery; when both spouses are transparent, much can be handled informally and inexpensively. Formal, court-enforced discovery becomes necessary when there is limited cooperation or genuine concern about hidden assets.
What happens at a deposition?
You answer questions under oath, outside court, with a court reporter recording your testimony. It is used to clarify facts, gather evidence, and assess credibility. Preparation with your attorney, honest and concise answers, and a calm demeanor are the keys to handling one well.
Will my contested divorce go to trial?
Most do not. As discovery clarifies the facts, many contested cases settle into a Marital Settlement Agreement. Trial becomes necessary when offers are grossly unfair, when a spouse negotiates in bad faith or hides assets, when there is domestic violence, or when complex valuation or serious parenting concerns require a judge to decide.
What if my spouse is hiding assets or playing dirty?
You have tools. Discovery and, where warranted, a forensic accountant can compel disclosure and trace concealed assets, and a court can sanction a spouse who obstructs the process. The best personal strategy is to document everything, keep communication factual and in writing, and avoid reacting in ways that muddy who is acting in good faith.
What does a Guardian ad Litem do?
In a disputed custody case, the GAL is a neutral attorney appointed to investigate and recommend what serves the children’s best interests. Because the judge weighs that recommendation heavily, it is important to be prepared, honest, child-focused, and cooperative when working with the GAL.
Who pays the legal fees in a contested divorce?
Each spouse generally pays from their own retainer at first, but under RSMo Section 452.355 a Missouri court can order a higher-earning spouse to contribute to the other’s reasonable litigation costs where there is an income disparity, and it can shift fees against a spouse who obstructs discovery.
Where is your St. Louis office located?
The Marks Law Firm serves the St. Louis metro from our Creve Coeur office at 4 Cityplace Dr #497, Creve Coeur, MO 63141, with additional offices in O’Fallon and St. Charles. You can reach us at (314) 720-8882 to schedule a consultation.
Why St. Louis Families Choose The Marks Law Firm
Since 1998, Jonathan D. Marks has focused his practice exclusively on Missouri family law, and he brings nearly three decades of contested-divorce and trial experience to families across the St. Louis region. He is board certified as a family trial advocate by the National Board of Trial Advocacy, a Fellow of the American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers and the International Academy of Family Lawyers, holds an AV Preeminent rating from Martindale-Hubbell, and has been recognized by Best Lawyers in America and by Super Lawyers among the top 50 attorneys in the St. Louis area.
In a contested case, that combination of trial credibility and negotiation skill is exactly what you want on your side. From our Creve Coeur office, convenient to the St. Louis City and St. Louis County courts, we help you protect your rights, your children, and your financial future.
Schedule A Consultation
Please Read: The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.
Can You Spend Money During a Missouri Divorce? What’s Allowed and What Triggers “Marital Waste” or “Marital Misconduct” Claims?
If you are going through a divorce in Missouri, you may be wondering whether you can continue spending money from joint bank accounts, pay routine
What If My Spouse Is Coaching the Kids Against Me During a Missouri Divorce?
Few life events fracture a person’s world quite like a divorce, turning a legal proceeding into a deeply personal, emotional restructuring of your entire life.
6 Questions to Ask Before Filing Divorce in St. Louis
Divorce is far more than a simple sequence of administrative legal filings. It represents a critical, often turbulent life transition that fundamentally reshapes a family’s